Appointment, Qualifications and Conditions of Service of High Court Judges

The appointment, qualifications and conditions of service of High Court judges are governed principally by Article 217 of the Constitution, which fixes who may become a High Court judge, how each judge is appointed, how long a judge may hold office, and the limited grounds on which a judge may leave office before retirement.

Appointment: From Presidential Consultation to Collegium

Article 217(1) provides that every Judge of a High Court is appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal, in consultation with the Governor of the State and, where the appointment is of a judge other than the Chief Justice, the Chief Justice of the High Court concerned. The Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014 had attempted to replace this consultation-based process with a recommendation from a National Judicial Appointments Commission under Article 124A, but the Supreme Court struck down this amendment. As a result, High Court judges continue to be appointed by the President after consultation with the Chief Justice of India and the State Governor, operating through the judicial "collegium" -- the Chief Justice of India together with senior judges -- which recommends names for appointment, giving primacy to the opinion of the Chief Justice of India where the constitutional functionaries involved in the process disagree. A specific Reference on this question, decided in 2009, held that the Chief Justice of India together with a collegium of senior judges forms the relevant authority for recommending High Court judge appointments, taking into account the views of the High Court's own Chief Justice.

Qualifications for Appointment

Under Article 217(2), a person is qualified for appointment as a High Court judge only if he or she is a citizen of India and has either held a judicial office in India for at least ten years, or has been an advocate of a High Court -- or of two or more such courts in succession -- for at least ten years.

Tenure and How a Judge Leaves Office

A High Court judge, once appointed as a permanent judge, holds office until attaining the age of sixty-two years (an additional or acting judge's tenure is separately governed by Article 224). A judge may leave office before this age limit in only two ways under Article 217: by resigning through a letter addressed to the President, or by being removed by the President in the manner the Constitution provides for removal. Where a dispute arises as to a judge's age, Article 217(3) provides for its determination.

Conditions of Service

Once appointed, a High Court judge's salary and related conditions of service are fixed by law and periodically revised -- the High Court and Supreme Court Judges (Conditions of Service) Amendment Act, 2018 enhanced the salaries of the Chief Justice and other judges of the High Courts, with retrospective effect from 1 January 2016. These conditions of service form part of the broader constitutional design of securing a High Court judge's independence once in office, alongside the fixed tenure and the narrow, constitutionally specified grounds for removal.

Constituent Assembly Concerns on Judicial Independence

The framers gave close attention to insulating the appointment process from purely executive control. Shrimati G. Durgabai argued in the Constituent Assembly that the procedure for appointing judges should involve consultation among multiple constitutional functionaries -- the President (or the head of the Federation), the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, the Governor, and the High Court's own Chief Justice -- because judicial independence depends on judges not owing their appointment to any single individual or political party, which requires the check of consultation among several authorities rather than a single appointing power.

UPSC Relevance

Prelims: Know the exact appointing authority (President, in consultation with the Governor and, for judges other than the Chief Justice, the High Court's Chief Justice), the two qualification routes (ten years as a judicial officer, or ten years as a High Court advocate), the retirement age of 62, and the two ways a judge may leave office before that age -- resignation and removal.

Mains: This topic is central to questions on judicial independence, the collegium system versus the National Judicial Appointments Commission, and the constitutional safeguards for a High Court judge's tenure and conditions of service.

FAQ

Q1. Who appoints a High Court judge? The President, by warrant under his hand and seal, in consultation with the Governor of the State and, for a judge other than the Chief Justice, the Chief Justice of the High Court concerned.

Q2. What are the qualifications for appointment as a High Court judge? Citizenship of India, and either at least ten years' experience holding a judicial office in India, or at least ten years as an advocate of a High Court (or of two or more such courts in succession).

Q3. Until what age does a High Court judge hold office? Sixty-two years, subject to the separate provisions for additional or acting judges under Article 224.

Q4. How can a High Court judge leave office before the retirement age? Only by resigning through a letter to the President, or by removal by the President in the constitutionally provided manner.

Q5. What happened to the National Judicial Appointments Commission's role in High Court judge appointments? The Ninety-ninth Amendment Act, 2014 sought to replace the earlier consultation process with NJAC recommendations, but the Supreme Court struck down this amendment, restoring the collegium-based consultation process.

Quick Revision

• Article 217(1): President appoints High Court judges after consulting the Governor and (for judges other than the Chief Justice) the High Court's Chief Justice.
• Article 217(2): qualification is Indian citizenship plus ten years as a judicial officer, or ten years as a High Court advocate (single or successive courts).
• Retirement age: 62 years for a permanent judge.
• A judge leaves office early only by resignation (letter to President) or removal by the President.
• Article 217(3): determination of disputes as to a judge's age.
• 99th Amendment (2014) tried to substitute NJAC recommendation for the consultation process; struck down by the Supreme Court.
• 2009 Reference: collegium of the Chief Justice of India and senior judges recommends High Court appointments, considering the views of the High Court's own Chief Justice.
• Salaries and conditions of service revised by the High Court and Supreme Court Judges (Conditions of Service) Amendment Act, 2018, with effect from 1 January 2016.

Sources

• Constitution of India, Article 217 -- legislative.gov.in
• Supreme Court of India -- Reference under Article 317(1), 2009

Further Reference

For deeper reading on this topic and the wider polity syllabus, these standard works are recommended:

• M. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity (McGraw Hill) -- the standard UPSC handbook.
• D.D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India (LexisNexis) -- authoritative constitutional-law treatment.
• The Constitution of India -- Bare Act -- the official text.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, UPSC.wiki earns from qualifying purchases -- at no extra cost to you.