Article 371J: Special Provisions for Karnataka

Karnataka Hyderabad region development sits at the heart of Article 371J, a special constitutional provision that lets the President place specific development responsibilities on the Governor of Karnataka. Inserted decades after most of the other Article 371 provisions, it is the newest addition to the Constitution's list of state-specific special arrangements and responds to a long-standing regional-backwardness problem rather than to linguistic reorganisation or law-and-order concerns like several of its neighbouring articles.

Background: Why Article 371J Was Added

The Hyderabad-Karnataka region — the part of Karnataka that had historically been part of the princely state of Hyderabad before the 1956 reorganisation of states — lagged behind the rest of Karnataka on several development indicators. In 2010, both Houses of the Karnataka Legislature, the Legislative Assembly and the Legislative Council, passed separate resolutions seeking special constitutional provisions for this region. The state government backed the demand, and the objective set out was to accelerate development in the state's most backward region and to promote inclusive growth by reducing inter-district and inter-regional disparities within Karnataka.

Acting on this demand, Parliament inserted Article 371J into the Constitution through the Constitution (Ninety-Eighth Amendment) Act, 2012. The provision came into force from 1 October 2013. It takes its place in Part XXI of the Constitution, titled "Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions," immediately after Article 371-I (Goa) and just before Article 372, making it the last in the sequence of state-specific special provisions running from Article 371 to Article 371J.

What Article 371J Provides

Article 371J operates in two clauses. Clause (1) empowers the President to make an order conferring special responsibility on the Governor of Karnataka for three things concerning the Hyderabad-Karnataka region:

• Establishment of a separate development board for the region, with a report on the board's working to be placed before the State Legislative Assembly every year.
• Equitable allocation of funds for developmental expenditure over the region, subject to the requirements of the state as a whole.
• Equitable opportunities and facilities for people belonging to the region in matters of public employment, education and vocational training, again subject to the requirements of the state as a whole.

Clause (2) then adds detail to the third limb. An order made under clause (1)(c) may provide for reservation of a proportion of seats in educational and vocational training institutions in the Hyderabad-Karnataka region for students who belong to the region by birth or domicile. It may also provide for identification of posts, or classes of posts, under the state government (or any body or organisation under the state government's control) in the region, with a proportion of such posts reserved for persons who belong to the region by birth or domicile, filled by direct recruitment, promotion, or any other manner specified in the order.

How the Governor's Special Responsibility Operates

Article 371J is one of several provisions in Part XXI that impose a "special responsibility" on a state Governor, a category distinct from the Governor's ordinary constitutional functions. In each case, the Governor exercises this responsibility according to directions issued by the President from time to time, and subject to those directions, acts in his own discretion. The scope of this discretionary power is not open-ended: the Supreme Court has held that a Governor's discretionary power is limited to the scope contemplated under Article 163(1), which applies only where a constitutional provision expressly requires the Governor to act in his individual judgment.

Several other states carry comparable special-responsibility clauses within Article 371 and its extensions, though each addresses a different regional concern:

Significance

Article 371J gives the Hyderabad-Karnataka region an institutional mechanism — a dedicated development board with an annual legislative report — aimed at correcting a historically skewed allocation of development funds. Its education and employment provisions are meant to build local human resources over time by reserving a share of seats and posts for people native to the region, rather than relying solely on general-category competition. As the most recent entrant into the Article 371 family, it also illustrates how India's asymmetric federalism continues to evolve: special constitutional arrangements are not frozen at 1950 or at the various state-reorganisation moments, but can still be added decades later in response to a state legislature's own resolutions.

UPSC Relevance

Prelims

• Article 371J was inserted by the 98th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2012, with effect from 1 October 2013.
• It is the last in the sequence of state-specific special provisions in Part XXI, from Article 371 to Article 371J.
• It applies specifically to the Hyderabad-Karnataka region within Karnataka, not the whole state.
• Clause (2) permits reservation of seats and posts for persons belonging to the region by birth or domicile.

Mains

• Discuss how Article 371J illustrates the continuing evolution of asymmetric federal arrangements in the Indian Constitution.
• Examine the role of a state legislature's resolution in triggering a constitutional amendment, using Article 371J as an example.
• Analyse the limits on a Governor's discretionary power while discharging a "special responsibility" under provisions like Article 371J.

FAQ

Q1. What is Article 371J of the Constitution? It is a provision that empowers the President to give the Governor of Karnataka special responsibility for the development of the Hyderabad-Karnataka region, covering a development board, equitable fund allocation, and equitable opportunities in employment, education and vocational training.

Q2. When was Article 371J inserted, and when did it come into force? It was inserted by the Constitution (Ninety-Eighth Amendment) Act, 2012, and came into force on 1 October 2013.

Q3. What triggered the insertion of Article 371J? In 2010, the Karnataka Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council passed resolutions seeking special constitutional provisions for the Hyderabad-Karnataka region, which the state government also endorsed, citing the region's backwardness relative to the rest of Karnataka.

Q4. Can reservations be made in jobs and education under Article 371J? Yes. Clause (2) allows an order to provide for reservation of a proportion of seats in educational and vocational training institutions, and of posts under the state government or bodies under its control, for persons belonging to the Hyderabad-Karnataka region by birth or domicile.

Q5. Does the Governor act alone in exercising this special responsibility? No. The Governor exercises the special responsibility according to directions issued by the President from time to time, and subject to those directions, acts in his own discretion within the limits recognised for discretionary power under Article 163(1).

Quick Revision

• Article 371J: special provisions for Karnataka's Hyderabad-Karnataka region.
• Inserted by the 98th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2012; in force from 1 October 2013.
• Preceded by 2010 resolutions of the Karnataka Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council.
• Clause (1): development board, equitable fund allocation, equitable opportunities in employment/education/vocational training.
• Clause (2): reservation of seats/posts for people of the region by birth or domicile.
• Last provision in the Part XXI sequence running from Article 371 to Article 371J.

Sources

• Constitution of India, Article 371J — legislative.gov.in
• Constitution (Ninety-Eighth Amendment) Act, 2012 — legislative.gov.in

Further Reference

For deeper reading on this topic and the wider polity syllabus, these standard works are recommended:

• M. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity (McGraw Hill) — the standard UPSC handbook.
• D.D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India (LexisNexis) — authoritative constitutional-law treatment.
• The Constitution of India — Bare Act — the official text.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, UPSC.wiki earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.