Article 199 defines a State Money Bill as one containing ONLY specified financial matters, with the Speaker's classification final.
At a glance
Article 199 defines a State Money Bill as one that contains ONLY specified financial matters.
Fines, licence/service fees, and local taxes do not by themselves make a Bill a Money Bill.
Classification decides whether a Bill follows the fast Article 198 route or the fuller Article 197 process.
Money bill definition for a State Legislature is set out in Article 199, which lists the exact financial matters a Bill must be confined to before it can be classified as a Money Bill and routed through the special, Assembly-dominant procedure of Article 198. The definition is a closed list, not an illustrative one.
The Matters Listed in Article 199(1)
Article 199(1) states that a Bill is deemed to be a Money Bill if it contains only provisions dealing with any or all of the following:
| Clause | Matter |
|---|---|
| (a) | Imposition, abolition, remission, alteration, or regulation of any tax |
| (b) | Regulation of the borrowing of money or giving of any guarantee by the State, or amendment of the law on the State's financial obligations |
| (c) | Custody of the Consolidated Fund or the Contingency Fund of the State, and payment into or withdrawal of money from such a Fund |
| (d) | Appropriation of moneys out of the Consolidated Fund of the State |
| (e) | Declaring any expenditure to be expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State, or increasing the amount of such expenditure |
| (f)-(g) | Receipt of money on account of the Consolidated Fund or public account of the State, and matters incidental to the matters above |
"Contains Only" Is the Strict Test
The defining word in Article 199(1) is "only." A Bill qualifies as a Money Bill solely if every one of its provisions falls within the listed matters. A Bill that deals mainly with a non-financial subject but happens to touch upon, say, expenditure from the Consolidated Fund as an incidental feature is not automatically a Money Bill; it is the Bill's exclusive content, not any single clause in it, that decides the classification. This strict, closed-list approach mirrors the identically structured definition for Parliament under Article 110, which lists the same categories of tax, borrowing, the Consolidated Fund and Contingency Fund of India, appropriation, and charged expenditure.
What Does Not, by Itself, Make a Bill a Money Bill
The Constitution is careful to keep some financial-looking provisions outside this special category. In the related provisions on financial Bills under Article 207, a Bill or amendment is not treated as falling within these money matters merely because it provides for fines or other pecuniary penalties, for fees charged for licences or for services rendered, or because it provides for the imposition, abolition, remission, alteration, or regulation of a tax levied by a local authority for local purposes. In other words, ordinary regulatory fines, service fees, and local-body taxation do not, by themselves, turn a Bill into a Money Bill.
Who Decides, and Why That Decision Cannot Be Reopened
Where a State has a Legislative Council, the question of whether a particular Bill is a Money Bill is decided by the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, and that decision is final. This certification is not a private formality: the Bill carries the Speaker's endorsement both when it is transmitted to the Legislative Council under Article 198 and again when it is presented to the Governor for assent under Article 200. Because the classification determines whether the Bill goes through the fourteen-day, Assembly-dominant Money Bill procedure or the longer, two-round suspensive process for ordinary bills, the Speaker's certificate effectively fixes the entire legislative path the Bill will follow.
Why the Definition Matters
Because a Money Bill excludes the Legislative Council from meaningful participation, the definition in Article 199 functions as a gatekeeping provision: only Bills genuinely confined to taxation, borrowing, the State's Funds, appropriation, and charged expenditure can bypass the Council's fuller role under Article 197. A Bill that mixes financial provisions with substantial non-financial policy content falls outside Article 199 and must instead follow the ordinary bill procedure, giving the Council its full three-month/one-month suspensive check.
UPSC Relevance
Prelims: Learn the closed list of matters in Article 199(1)(a)-(g) — tax, borrowing/guarantees, the Consolidated/Contingency Fund, appropriation, and charged expenditure — and remember that the Bill must contain ONLY these matters. Also note that mere fines, licence fees, or local-body taxes do not make a Bill a Money Bill, and that the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly's classification is final.
Mains: Discuss why the Constitution confines the Money Bill definition to a closed list of matters and gives the Speaker final, unchallengeable authority to classify a Bill, and what risks or benefits this concentration of classificatory power carries for the balance between the two Houses of a bicameral State Legislature.
FAQ
Q1. Which article defines "Money Bill" for a State Legislature? A. Article 199 of the Constitution.
Q2. What is the key test for whether a Bill is a Money Bill? A. It must contain ONLY provisions dealing with the matters listed in Article 199(1) — tax, borrowing/guarantees, the Consolidated Fund or Contingency Fund of the State, appropriation, and charged expenditure, or matters incidental to these.
Q3. Does a Bill become a Money Bill just because it imposes a fine or a fee? A. No. Provisions for fines, pecuniary penalties, or fees for licences and services rendered do not, by themselves, bring a Bill within the Money Bill category.
Q4. Does a local tax provision make a Bill a Money Bill? A. No. A tax imposed, altered, or regulated by a local authority for local purposes does not by itself qualify a Bill as a Money Bill.
Q5. Who decides whether a Bill is a Money Bill, and can that decision be challenged? A. The Speaker of the Legislative Assembly decides, and the decision is final.
Quick Revision
- Article 199 = definition of "Money Bill" for a State Legislature.
- A Bill is a Money Bill only if it contains ONLY the matters listed in Article 199(1)(a)-(g).
- Listed matters: tax; borrowing/guarantees; Consolidated/Contingency Fund custody; appropriation; charged expenditure; incidental matters.
- Fines, licence/service fees, and local-body taxes do NOT by themselves create a Money Bill.
- Speaker of the Legislative Assembly's classification of a Bill as a Money Bill is final.
- Article 199 is structurally parallel to Article 110, the Union definition of Money Bill.
- Classification under Article 199 determines whether a Bill follows the Article 198 (Money Bill) or Article 197 (ordinary bill) procedure.
Sources
- Constitution of India, Article 199 — https://www.indiacode.nic.in/
- Constitution of India, Article 207 — https://www.indiacode.nic.in/
- Constitution of India, Article 110 (Union parallel) — https://www.indiacode.nic.in/
Further Reference
For deeper reading on this topic and the wider polity syllabus, these standard works are recommended:
- M. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity (McGraw Hill) — the standard UPSC handbook.
- D.D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India (LexisNexis) — authoritative constitutional-law treatment.
- The Constitution of India — Bare Act — the official text.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, UPSC.wiki earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.
Constitutional provisions
Defines Money Bill for a State Legislature via a closed list of financial matters.
Clarifies that fines, fees, and local taxes do not by themselves fall within Article 199 matters.
Union parallel definition of Money Bill for Parliament.