Public Services: All-India Services and Constitutional Basis (Articles 308-314)

All India services are administrative cadres — the Indian Administrative Service, Indian Police Service and Indian Forest Service among them — recruited on a common all-India basis but serving interchangeably under both the Union and the States. Their creation, staffing and discipline rest on a single scheme in Part XIV of the Constitution, Articles 308 to 323, which also sets up the Public Service Commissions that recruit into and advise on these services.

Part XIV at a Glance

Article	Subject
308	Interpretation of "State" for this Part
309	Recruitment and conditions of service
310	Tenure of office of persons serving the Union or a State
311	Safeguards against dismissal, removal or reduction in rank
312	All-India Services
312A	Power of Parliament to vary conditions of service of certain officers
313	Transitional provisions
314	Omitted
315–323	Public Service Commissions for the Union and the States
335	Claims of SCs and STs to services and posts

Article 308: Setting the Scope

Article 308 clarifies that, for Part XIV, "State" carries the same meaning as elsewhere in the Constitution, subject to an exception that once excluded Jammu and Kashmir. It exists mainly to fix which governments the service-related articles that follow actually govern.

Article 309: Recruitment and Conditions of Service

Article 309 gives the "appropriate Legislature" — Parliament for Union services, a State Legislature for State services — power to make laws on recruitment and conditions of service. Until such a law exists, the President or Governor may issue rules covering the same ground; an executive rule gives way once the legislature acts. This keeps the administrative machinery functioning even where no dedicated service law has yet been passed.

Articles 310–311: Tenure and Protection from Arbitrary Action

Article 310 provides that persons serving the Union or a State generally hold office during the pleasure of the President or Governor. Article 311 tempers this by requiring that a civil servant facing dismissal, removal or reduction in rank be given a reasonable opportunity to be heard. Together, the two provisions balance the government's control over its personnel with protection against arbitrary punitive action.

Article 312: The Constitutional Basis of All-India Services

Article 312 is the specific foundation for creating new All-India Services common to the Union and the States. Legislating on State services would ordinarily fall outside Parliament's reach, but Article 312 carves out an exception: Parliament may create such a service once the Rajya Sabha adopts a resolution, by not less than a two-thirds majority of members present and voting, declaring it necessary or expedient in the national interest. Once created, the service is staffed through common recruitment, with officers allotted to cadres across States and the Union — giving the administration a shared character at both levels of government.

This is one of four special powers the Rajya Sabha alone holds — the others being authorising Parliament to legislate on a State List subject, initiating removal of the Vice-President, and letting an emergency proclamation survive dissolution of the Lok Sabha — even though it cannot make or unmake a government or move a cut motion.

Article 312A additionally lets Parliament vary or revoke the service conditions of officers appointed, before the Constitution commenced, to a former princely state or a Part B State.

Article 313: Continuity from the Pre-Constitution Regime

Article 313 preserves continuity: laws in force immediately before the Constitution's commencement, so far as they applied to public services and public servants, continue to operate until altered by a competent authority, provided they remain consistent with the Constitution. This avoided any gap in service rules during the transition from colonial administration. Article 314, which offered a comparable protection to certain existing officers, has since been omitted.

Public Service Commissions: Articles 315–323

Chapter II of Part XIV sets up a Public Service Commission for the Union and one for each State, with provision for a Joint Commission serving two or more States. The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) has a Chairman and other members appointed by the President, who also fixes their number. A member holds office for six years or until age 65, whichever is earlier, and can be removed only through a process akin to impeachment — meant to insulate the Commission from routine political pressure.

Article 319 restricts a Commission member's further government employment after retirement, protecting the integrity of recruitment. Under Article 320, its principal task is conducting examinations for the All-India Services, Central Services and Union Territory services, besides advising government on promotions, transfers and disciplinary matters, and assisting States that jointly seek help with recruitment schemes. Article 322 charges the Commission's expenses on the Consolidated Fund, outside the annual parliamentary vote, though Parliament may still discuss them.

Article 335: Balancing Representation and Efficiency

Article 335 requires that the claims of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes be considered, consistently with maintaining administrative efficiency, when making appointments to Union and State services. It works alongside Article 16(4), which lets the State reserve posts for backward classes it finds inadequately represented in public employment — tying Part XIV's recruitment framework to the Constitution's wider social-justice commitments without displacing efficiency as a criterion.

Why the Framers Treated the Commission Differently from the Judiciary

In the Constituent Assembly on 25 May 1949, Dr B.R. Ambedkar explained why post-retirement restrictions on Public Service Commission members were not extended to judges. The Commission, he noted, constantly decides matters in which the Executive has a direct interest — recruitment to the civil service — creating a real risk that a minister could sway a member with the prospect of future office. Judges mostly decide disputes between private citizens, with government rarely a party, so that risk does not arise in the same way. This is why Part XIV builds tighter, specific safeguards around the Public Service Commissions rather than applying one uniform rule to every constitutional office-holder.

UPSC Relevance

Prelims

• Article 312 requires a Rajya Sabha resolution by a two-thirds majority before Parliament can create a new All-India Service — one of the Rajya Sabha's four special powers.
• UPSC members hold office for six years or till age 65, whichever is earlier; removable only through an impeachment-like process.
• Article 319 restricts a Commission member's further government employment after retirement.
• Article 335 links SC/ST representation in services to the maintenance of administrative efficiency.
• Article 322 charges Commission expenses on the Consolidated Fund, outside Parliament's vote.

Mains

• Examine how Article 312 reflects federal and unitary elements in India's administrative structure. (GS2)
• Discuss how Articles 310–311 and 315–323 keep the civil service and Public Service Commissions independent of political pressure. (GS2)
• Analyse the interplay between Article 16(4), Article 335 and Part XIV's recruitment framework. (GS2)

FAQ

What is the constitutional basis for All-India Services? Article 312 lets Parliament create an All-India Service common to the Union and the States, but only after the Rajya Sabha passes a resolution by a two-thirds majority declaring it necessary in the national interest.

Which articles govern recruitment and dismissal of civil servants? Article 309 empowers Parliament or State Legislatures to make service-recruitment laws, with the President or Governor filling the gap through rules until such a law exists. Article 311 protects civil servants from dismissal, removal or reduction in rank without a reasonable opportunity to be heard.

How are Union Public Service Commission members appointed and removed? The Chairman and members of the UPSC are appointed by the President and hold office for six years or until age 65, whichever is earlier. They can be removed only through a process akin to impeachment.

What is the significance of Article 335? It requires that the claims of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes be considered in making appointments to services and posts, but consistently with maintaining administrative efficiency.

Why does the Rajya Sabha have a special role in creating All-India Services? Since All-India Services touch subjects otherwise within the States' domain, Article 312 requires the Rajya Sabha, seen as representing the States, to first resolve by a two-thirds majority that such a service is necessary in the national interest.

Quick Revision

• Part XIV: Articles 308–323 — public services and Public Service Commissions.
• Article 309: legislature regulates recruitment/conditions; President/Governor make rules till then.
• Article 310: tenure during pleasure; Article 311: safeguards against arbitrary dismissal.
• Article 312: All-India Services via Rajya Sabha resolution, two-thirds majority.
• Article 313: pre-Constitution service laws continue; Article 314: omitted.
• Articles 315–323: UPSC/SPSC; members serve six years or till 65; Article 319 bars easy re-employment.
• Article 335: SC/ST claims to services, consistent with administrative efficiency.

Sources

• The Constitution of India, Part XIV (Articles 308–323) and Article 335 — Ministry of Law and Justice, legislative.gov.in
• Union Public Service Commission — official website, upsc.gov.in
• Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. VIII, proceedings of 25 and 30 May 1949 — official records, Parliament of India

Further Reference

For deeper reading on this topic and the wider polity syllabus, these standard works are recommended:

• M. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity (McGraw Hill) — the standard UPSC handbook.
• D.D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India (LexisNexis) — authoritative constitutional-law treatment.
• The Constitution of India — Bare Act — the official text.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, UPSC.wiki earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.